Searching for Life
Adapted from “It’s Alive!” from Destination: Mars, NASA Johnson Space Center, 2002.
In this 45–60-minute indoor activity, children ages 8–13 discuss how life is defined and conduct a simple experiment, looking for signs of life in three different “soil” samples. The experiment introduces the children to the difficulty that scientists face in defining life. By observing the soil samples, the children try to determine if any contain signs of life and work to identify, refine, and create a set of characteristics that may be used to identify living versus nonliving things. The activity concludes with the development of a group definition of life. This group definition will be important, and should be referred to as the children work through the subsequent module activities (if they are undertaken).
This activity complements the later Mars Engineering activity and can be combined with a presentation by an astrobiologist, planetary scientist, or NASA Solar System Ambassador, if desired. It is highly recommended that this activity be preceded by the Ice Breaker activity.
What's the Point?
- When scientists look for life, the signs are not always easy to determine.
- Natural chemical reactions could be confused with evidence for life.
- There is no firm scientific definition of life, no single test that can prove its presence or absence, and no single characteristic that applies to all living things. For example, mountains may grow but are not alive. Fire can also grow, take in nutrients (oxygen and fuel), and give off waste products. However, fire is not considered to be a living thing. Scientists need to use multiple tests and characteristics to define life.
- Living things have certain recognizable properties.
- There are characteristics that almost all living things share.
- Scientists use a group definition of life to conduct their research, and Explore: Life on Mars? participants will likewise use a group definition to conduct activities in the module.
- One basic definition of life is that it does something, and that it keeps on doing it.
- Use group work and collaboration to help engage children. Girls benefit from collaboration, especially when they can participate and communicate fairly. Girls are energized by the social part of science, working and learning together. This activity gives the children the opportunity to collaborate and work together in a fun and engaging social environment.
- Encourage critical thinking. Girls gain confidence and trust in their own reasoning when encouraged to think critically. This activity provides an opportunity for children to use their observational skills and think critically about identifying signs of life.
- Expose girls to female role models who have achieved in math and science in order to promote positive beliefs regarding women’s abilities. If possible, have a female speaker share the science of astrobiology, and how scientists look for life in the universe. This activity also provides activity pages, Scientist Spotlight pages, and Trading Cards featuring female (and male) astrobiologists as an additional resource to connect children with careers in science and to challenge existing stereotypes of scientists.
For each pair of children:
- 3 (clean) plastic cups (5–8 oz.), clear if available
- ¾ to 1 cup of sand, enough to fill each cup ¼ full
- 3 teaspoons (tsp.) sugar
- 1 teaspoon (tsp.) instant active dry yeast
- 1 tablet of crushed (as finely as possible) Alka-Seltzer® or comparable fizzing tablets
- hot water, enough to cover the sand in each cup (not hot enough to kill the yeast)
- 1 pitcher, carafe, or other appropriate container for the hot water
- optional: library books related to the topic (suggested book list below)
- optional: a variety of colorful Post-It® notes
For each child:
For the facilitator:
- background information
- shopping list
- flip chart, white board, or blackboard and appropriate writing utensils
- permanent marker for writing on the cups
- 3 craft sticks or spoons (for mixing cups A, B, and C)
- container (large mug, cup, or pitcher) of water to fill all the cups to cover the sand (you should use water that is between 105° and 115°F; check the temperature with the thermometer).
- optional: article on “Defining Life”
- Review the activity procedures, activity pages, and background information.
- Prepare 1 set of 3 cups for each pair of children before the event/program: Each cup will contain sand and should be approximately ¼ full of sand. Each cup should also contain 1 tsp. of sugar.
- Mark one cup “A.” This cup should contain only the sand and sugar. Mix well using a craft stick or spoon.
- Mark the second cup “B.” Add 1 finely crushed tablet of Alka-Seltzer® or other comparable fizzing tablet to the sand and sugar. Mix well using a craft stick or spoon.
- Mark the last cup “C.” Add 1 tsp. instant active dry yeast to the sand and sugar. Mix well using a craft stick or spoon.
Note: Make sure to use a different stirring stick/spoon for each type of cup (A, B, and C) to avoid cross-contamination.
- If possible, invite an astrobiologist, planetary scientist, or NASA Solar System Ambassador to present during the program/event. Consider the following tips for selecting a guest presenter and impacting persisting stereotypes:
- Invite a female or representative of another underrepresented group.
- Invite a dynamic, personable speaker to counteract the stereotype that scientists are solitary and boring.
- Make copies of Extreme-O-File: Searching for Life activity pages
- Optional: Select and set aside library books and resources related to the topic.
- Acquire a selection of books about astrobiology
Divide the children into small groups of 2–3 children each.
1. Welcome and introduce the topic/module. Explain to the children that in this activity, they are going to discuss how we define life and conduct an experiment to test for the signs of life (much like a rover on Mars may do) – creating a group definition of life to use in later activities. Having a clear definition is important for scientists, too. In order for a rover, like the Curiosity rover on Mars, to find signs of life, scientists need to have a clear understanding of what to look for — how to identify living versus non–living!
2. Ask the children what the characteristics of life are. Invite the children to work in their small groups and then to share their answers and examples. Write their responses on the White Board/Poster/Chalk Board. Optional: You may write their responses on colorful Post–It ® notes and post them on a poster or wall.
As a group, you should work to create an initial definition for life together that they will use as they move on to complete more of the Explore: Life on Mars? activities. Optional: Have the children record their definition (set of characteristics) on their Extreme–O–File activity page. Note: If you have previously conducted the Ice Breaker activity, you should incorporate the characteristics compiled during that activity here and add to them/refine them.
- What are some examples of living things? Cat, dog, tree, flowers, grass, many possible answers here
- What are some examples of non–living things? Car, TV, table, many possible answers here
- What tells you that something is alive (i.e., characteristics of living things)? How can you tell that it is alive? It moves, breathes, eats, reproduces, it responds to changes in its environment, many possible answers here.
- Living example: A cat needs to be fed and watered, provided shelter. It can breathe, move on its own, reproduce, and respond to its environment (make choices).
- Non–living example: A car “eats” or consumes a fuel (gas), and its engine need to “breathe” (i.e., take in fresh air and release used air — exhaust), but it is not alive. It cannot reproduce, move on its own (needs an operator), or respond to its environment (make decisions).
- One (single) characteristic cannot be used to distinguish between living and nonliving. We need to develop more tests (questions) that we can use together to determine the presence of life. Scientists also have to do this!
3. Invite the children to conduct an experiment searching for signs of life in three different “alien” samples, based on the characteristics they defined. Pass each small group the 3 prepared cups A, B, and C, and a copy of the Extreme–O–File: Searching for Life activity page.
- Examine your samples — look and even smell the samples (do not taste them). Fill in the first observation on your observation page.
- Do you detect any visible evidence of life? No — Unless they recognize the yeast, there won’t be any true evidence of life yet.
4. Invite the children to add hot water to their samples. Pass around the hot water to the children and ask them to add the water to each cup, filling it up halfway (to completely cover the sand and leave some water on top). Alternatively, fill the cups to the appropriate level for them. Note: Caution them to be careful while handling the hot water.
- What do you notice? Invite them to make observations and record their observations (optional).
After a few minutes…
- Ask the children what they see, smell, and feel. Invite them to share what they’ve seen. They should comment that the second cup, B, is showing a reaction with bubbling.
5. Discuss the definition of life with the children, while the water continues to react with the materials in the cups. Discuss the scientific perspective on life, and consider how life might be different on other planets. Encourage all ideas, and write their responses on the flip chart/white board.
- How can you tell living things apart from nonliving things (recall the Ice Breaker Activity if applicable)? If it moves, breathes, eats, reproduces, learns, uses energy, is made of cells, grows, evolves, respond to changes in the environment, produces waste, etc.
6. Observe any further changes in the “alien” samples. Ask the children to observe their three cups again and record their last observations.
- What do you see, smell, and feel? Invite them to share the changes that they’ve observed. (Cup B should no longer be reacting. Cup C may be warmer to the touch than the other cups, and should have a layer of foam on top, and a yeast/dough smell.)
- What is the evidence of life? Are any of the cups showing something happening and continuing to happen? (The quick reaction in cup B is a chemical reaction, not an indication of life. Cup C is demonstrating a sustained reaction.)
Describe the ingredients for each cup, and for each cup, ask whether the sample contained life. Describe the yeast sample last. Let the children know that yeast is a fungus that was growing, using the sugar and giving off carbon dioxide, which created the foam. While they could not see the yeast itself (it is microscopic), they were able to observe signs of life, such as the foam and gas bubbles. They may have also noticed that the cup was getting warmer — another sign of life from the yeast. Scientists suspect that any life present on Mars would have been (or is) microscopic (i.e., too small to see with the human eye). Thus, scientists need to observe for signs of life much like the children have just done!
Revisit the group definition/set of the characteristics of life. Do you have any changes or additions to make to your definition? If so, add/change as needed. Have the children record it their findings in their Extreme-O-File activity pages.
Studying (unicellular) yeast cells, such as those in the experimental cup C, has provided many scientific advances in biology over the years. Yeast has even made it into space to study the effects of microgravity. In fact, researchers today are using yeast to help understand the development of multicellular life forms that exist on Earth today, alongside the unicellular forms. By understanding how life developed on Earth, they hope to understand how life may have developed beyond our planet.
For more information about how yeast is being used to study the origin of life, please visit astrobio.net/components/com_news/newsPrintDetail.php?id=4477.
Ask the children whether it was difficult to identify the soil sample with life. If so, why? Which of their senses were most useful as they were observing? Note that scientists use instruments to make observations. For example, they can use instruments that measure the chemical composition of air as a remote form of “smell” on another planet (like Mars). Did the children use their noses and notice any differences between the “soil” samples during the activity?
Summarize the experiment and its results. How did this experiment affect and help you to create your group definition of life?
Share that, while at first it might seem like determining if something is alive or not is easy, defining life is actually much more difficult than many people realize. Optional: Have the children record the group definition in their activity pages.
Revisit your refined group definition. Explain how an experiment may be used in missions (such as their rovers) to search for signs of life in other places, such as Mars. By refining our understanding of life, we are better able to look for it elsewhere. This is what astrobiology strives to do!
Defining life is not a simple task and even scientists do not completely agree on all the characteristics that should be used to do so. Tell the children that they will refine their group definition as they continue to explore the possibilities of life on Mars in the later activities.