Lunar and Planetary Institute
Lunar and Planetary Institute



The End of Planet Formation, as Told by Trace Elements from the Mantles of Earth, the Moon, and Mars

December 10, 2010
Source: Southwest Research Institute, Boulder

Planet impactNew research reveals that the abundance of so-called highly siderophile, or metal-loving, elements like gold and platinum found in the mantles of Earth, the Moon, and Mars were delivered by massive impactors during the final phase of planet formation over 4.5 billion years ago.

The predicted sizes of the projectiles, which hit within tens of millions of years of the giant impact that produced our Moon, are consistent with current planet formation models as well as physical evidence such as the size distributions of asteroids and ancient martian impact scars. They predict that the largest of the late impactors on Earth, at 1500–2000 miles in diameter, potentially modified Earth’s obliquity by approximately 10°, while those for the Moon, at approximately 150–200 miles, may have delivered water to its mantle.

The team that conducted this study comprises solar system dynamicists William Bottke and David Nesvorny from the Southwest Research Institute in Boulder, and geophysical-geochemical modelers Richard J. Walker from the University of Maryland, James Day from the University of Maryland and Scripps Institution of Oceanography, and Linda Elkins-Tanton from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Together, they represent three teams within the NASA Lunar Science Institute (NLSI).

A fundamental problem in planetary science is to determine how Earth, the Moon, and other inner solar system planets formed and evolved. This is a difficult question to answer given that billions of years of history have steadily erased evidence for these early events. Despite this, critical clues can still be found to help determine what happened, provided one knows where to look.

For instance, careful study of lunar samples brought back by the Apollo astronauts, combined with numerical modeling work, indicates that the Moon formed as a result of a collision between a Mars-sized body and the early Earth about 4.5 billion years ago. While the idea that the Earth-Moon system owes its existence to a single, random event was initially viewed as radical, it is now believed that such large impacts were commonplace during the end stages of planet formation. The giant impact is believed to have led to a final phase of core formation and global magma oceans on both Earth and the Moon.

For the giant impact hypothesis to be correct, one might expect samples from Earth and the Moon's mantle, brought to the surface by volcanic activity, to back it up. In particular, scientists have examined the abundance in these rocks of so-called highly siderophile, or metal-loving, elements:  Re, Os, Ir, Ru, Pt, Rh, Pd, Au. These elements should have followed the iron and other metals to the core in the aftermath of the Moon-forming event, leaving the rocky crusts and mantles of these bodies void of these elements. Accordingly, their near-absence from mantle rocks should provide a key test of the giant impact model.

However, as described by team member Walker, "The big problem for the modelers is that these metals are not missing at all, but instead are modestly plentiful." Team member Day adds, "This is a good thing for anyone who likes their gold wedding rings or the cleaner air provided by the palladium in their car's catalytic convertors."

A proposed solution to this conundrum is that highly siderophile elements were indeed stripped from the mantle by the effects of the giant impact, but were then partially replenished by later impacts from the original building blocks of the planets, called planetesimals. This is not a surprise — planet formation models predict such late impacts — but their nature, numbers, and most especially size of the accreting bodies are unknown. Presumably, they could have represented the accretion of many small bodies or a few large events. To match observations, the late-arriving planetesimals need to deliver 0.5% of Earth's mass to Earth's mantle, equivalent to one-third the mass of the Moon, and about 1200 times less mass to the Moon's mantle.

Using numerical models, the team showed that they could reproduce these amounts if the late accretion population was dominated by massive projectiles. Their results indicate the largest Earth impactor was 1500—2000 miles in diameter, roughly the size of Pluto, while those hitting the Moon were only 150–200 miles across. Lead author Bottke says, "These impactors are thought to be large enough to produce the observed enrichments in highly siderophile elements, but not so large that their fragmented cores joined with the planet's core. They probably represent the largest objects to hit those worlds since the giant impact that formed our Moon."

Intriguingly, the predicted distribution of projectile sizes, where most of the mass of the population is found among the largest objects, is consistent with other evidence.

These results make it possible to make some interesting predictions about the evolution of Earth, Mars, and the Moon. For example:

The article, "Stochastic Late Accretion to the Earth, Moon, and Mars," appears in the December 10 issue of Science.

For more information, visit

NASA Lunar Science Institute

Community News home page


Last updated December 10, 2010